Introduction Asrar Rashid of Birmingham, UK, is a preacher who claims to be non-partisan, non-sectarian, and an objective, unbiased “Sunnī Muslim”. However, the subjectivity, and often baselessness, of his claims on the nature and roots of one of the most pronounced intra-Sunnī divides in the Indian Subcontinent proves otherwise. His …
Read More »Questions for Dr Akram Nadwi on his Advice to Nadwa Graduates
In an Urdu article entitled “Three Points for the New Generation of Nadwa (Nadwa ki Jadeed Nasl se Teen Baateinh)”, Dr Akram Nadwi offers three pieces of advice to new graduates of Nadwat al-Ulama, Lucknow, to ensure their first steps after graduation lead them in the right direction and they …
Read More »In Defence of the Variant Qur’anic Readings (Qirā’āt)
[Translator’s Note: The following excerpt is a translation of the preface to Difā-i-Qirā’āt, a masterpiece authored by the erudite scholar, Qārī Muḥammad Ṭāhir Raḥīmī al-Madanī (raḥimahullāh). The Urdu work, close to nine hundred pages long, is a detailed response to the feeble objections of a notorious hadith rejecter, Tamanna ‘Imadi …
Read More »“To My Friends, Supporters and Well Wishers” – Dr Akram Nadwi’s Advice
To my friends, supporters and well wishers by: Dr Mohammad Akram Nadwi Oxford While I am grateful to you for your kindness and good intentions in defending me, on the internet and on social media, from those who criticise my opinions and arguments, I must respectfully ask you: please stop! …
Read More »Zakat: Methodology, Categories and Scope – A Critique of NZF’s Strategy Document
Introduction National Zakat Foundation (NZF), which describes itself as “UK’s only Zakāt institution”, has recently released a relatively lengthy document outlining the juristic positions it adopts on basic Zakāt-related matters with an explanation of how these positions were reached.[1] The document rightly cautions that “Zakat is a pillar of Islam …
Read More »الرد على الأستاذ محمد أكرم الندوي في إنكاره حادثة السحر
الرد على الاستاذ أكرم الندوي في انكاره لحادثة السحر بقلم الشيخ المحدث مولانا لطيف الرحمن القاسمي حفظه الله، مكة المكرمة ويليه اصل المقالة للأستاذ الندوي In-sha-Allah, a translation of the above article will be uploaded soon.
Read More »Debunking Nahiem Ajmal’s Misquoting of Tahir Ibn ‘Ashur on the Beast
When people become hellbent on proving their viewpoint to be true, no matter how ridiculous it may be, it is common to see them gleefully embrace any information that confirms their view but dismiss or undermine anything that contests it. For people of this bizarre disposition, or “confirmation bias” to …
Read More »Quoting out of Context: Nahiem Ajmal (Abu Layth) on Prophet Isa Speaking in the Cradle
Academic Integrity “Why can’t we just be honest as scholars?”: an ironic but excellent question posed by Nahiem Ajmal (Abu Layth al-Maliki). Regardless of where one aligns themselves in terms of beliefs and viewpoints, everyone appreciates academic integrity. Inadvertently misquoting or misrepresenting others may reflect poor scholarship at the most, …
Read More »The Mahdī in Sunnī Belief
There has historically been general agreement amongst the Ahl al-Sunnah wa l-Jamā‘ah on the belief in the “Mahdī”, that is, a man by the name of “Muḥammad” from the descendants of the Prophet (ṣallallāhu ‘alayhi wasallam) will emerge at the end of time who will rule the Muslim lands for …
Read More »Istiḥsān in the Ḥanafī School – A Response to Dr Asim Yusuf
Dr Asim Yusuf, author of Shedding Light on the Dawn, recently delivered a talk at Ebrahim College on the “Anatomy of a Fatwa,” in which he made several startling claims. His talk was apparently aimed at showing that we are in a “post-madhhab age” and fiqh has to be conducted …
Read More »